Castaways Pizza & Grill

Nestled in the heart of Conneaut, Ohio, Castaways Pizza & Grill offers a welcoming escape for pizza lovers and casual diners craving hearty, flavorful meals. Specializing in classic American fare with a vibrant twist, this beloved pizza restaurant serves up a diverse menu that goes far beyond the ordinary slice.

Whether you're in the mood for a perfectly crisp Pepperoni Pizza dotted with rich, gooey cheese or the indulgent Meat Lovers Pizza piled high with savory toppings, Castaways satisfies every craving. The menu showcases a tantalizing range of options, from the crisp and fresh Grilled Chicken Salad and the comforting Eggplant Parmigiana to the robust flavors of The Godfather Italian Sub and the golden, crispy Piece Wing Basket Shrimp. For those who love loaded fries, their crispy, generously topped Loaded Fries and the irresistibly sweet Sweet Potato Fries are absolute must-tries.

Each dish bursts with vibrant flavors and generous portions that comfort and delight with every bite. Patrons rave about the freshness and attention to detail — from the tangy kick of their Reuben Sandwich to the melty, savory goodness found in the Ham and Cheese Calzone. Meanwhile, the beverage selection, featuring craft draft beers, wines, and refreshing iced teas, perfectly complements the bold, hearty fare.

Step inside Castaways Pizza & Grill and you're greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. The space is clean, thoughtfully decorated, and buzzing with positive energy. Customers often highlight the friendly, attentive staff who make every visit feel special. Whether you're dining solo, enjoying a casual lunch with coworkers, or gathering with friends after a day at the lake, the welcoming vibe makes it an ideal spot to relax and indulge.

Regular guests like Hannah Best and Helen Androw praise the freshness of the food and the genuine hospitality, underscoring why this gem remains a favorite in the Conneaut area. Enthusiasts such as Richard Otero appreciate the large, satisfying portions and the unwavering quality across multiple visits — from savory spaghetti dishes to the beloved cheese pizza slices, every meal is “yummy for the tummy.” Jonathon York’s experience discovering Castaways during a pizza crawl highlights the impressive beer selection and the festive, cozy ambiance, perfect for any occasion.

For an authentic taste of Conneaut’s pizza scene paired with a broad menu of crowd-pleasers and a friendly, clean setting, Castaways Pizza & Grill is a must-visit. Their commitment to consistently hot, fresh, and delicious meals ensures every visit leaves you planning your next one.

Castaways Pizza & Grill
877 Broad St, Conneaut, OH 44030
Phone: +1 440-599-8187