Castaways Pizza & Grill Menu

Castaways Pizza & Grill in Conneaut, OH, offers a diverse menu that perfectly balances classic comfort foods with flavorful twists. Known for their hearty and generous portions, the menu shines with standout dishes like their Pepperoni and Meat Lovers Pizzas, each topped with extra cheese for that perfect gooey bite. Beyond pizza, the Loaded Fries and Sweet Potato Fries add a satisfying crunch, while the Reuben Sandwich and Chicken Parm Sandwich deliver rich, savory layers that comfort the soul. For seafood lovers, the Fisherman’s Platter and Piece Wing Basket Shrimp bring a fresh taste from the lake, paired well with their craft beer selection. The menu even caters to little appetites with kid-friendly options like Mac & Cheese and grilled cheese sandwiches. The standout is the balance of classic American fare and specialty subs, such as The Godfather Italian, all served with a friendly, welcoming atmosphere that keeps guests coming back for more.